Lone Worker Device vs Mobile App: Which Personal Safety Solution Is Best?

Choosing between a lone worker device or app depends on your employees' risk levels, work environments, and safety needs — ensuring the right solution helps you stay compliant, protect lone workers effectively, and support their wellbeing at all times.

Lone Worker Device or App: Which Should You Choose?

When it comes to protecting lone and remote workers, many employers ask:
Should we invest in a personal safety device, use a mobile app, or both?

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. The right solution depends on your employees’ roles, risk levels, working environments, and practical requirements.

This blog breaks down the key differences between dedicated lone worker devices and mobile safety apps, helping you make the best choice for your team.

Personal Safety Device vs Lone Worker App: A Side-by-Side Comparison

Feature	Lone Worker Device	Mobile Safety App
Best For	High-risk roles (e.g. field engineers, social workers, retail staff)	Low to medium-risk roles (e.g. office-based, hybrid workers)
Emergency Support	Discreet Red Alert button — quick access	Discreet Activation available on Android mobiles
Fall Detection (Man Down)	Available on all devices	Available on the app
Battery Life	Long-lasting (8–72+ hours)	Depends on phone usage & charge
Deployment Speed	Requires distribution and setup	Quick setup on smartphones
Cost	Higher per-user cost	Lower-cost, scalable option
Ideal Use Cases	Lone working in hazardous, isolated, or public-facing environments	Flexible, hybrid roles with minimal physical risk

Benefits of Using a Dedicated Lone Worker Safety Device

Lone worker devices are purpose-built for safety. They offer:

Fast access to help in a discreet, physical format (ideal during confrontation)
Reliable performance with long battery life and minimal phone dependency
Man Down alerts for detecting incapacitation without user input

They’re ideal for:

Field workers in unpredictable environments
Public-facing roles prone to aggression
Workers in remote areas with limited phone coverage

➡️ Explore our Lone Worker Devices: ID Touch, Shield, Curve, Go and ID Classic

When to Use a Lone Worker App for Personal Safety

Safety apps offer flexible protection, especially for:

Office staff working from home or on the go
Employees using company-issued or personal smartphones
Organisations looking to scale protection affordably

Modern safety apps offer:

Red Alert, Check-In, and location tracking
Risk Messaging functionality during crises
Easy integration with employee onboarding

➡️ Learn more about the SoloProtect Mobile App for iOS and Android.

Hybrid Lone Worker Safety Solutions: Combining Apps and Devices

Many organisations combine devices and apps based on job roles and risk levels. This flexible model allows you to:

Prioritise investment for high-risk roles
Deploy quickly to lower-risk staff
Evolve the solution as your workforce grows or diversifies

How to Choose the Best Lone Worker Solution: Key Questions to Ask

Who responds to a lone worker emergency alert, and how quickly?

When a lone worker triggers an emergency alert—often called a Red Alert—response time is critical. It’s important to ask whether the solution includes 24/7 monitoring by a dedicated Alarm Receiving Centre (ARC) or if alerts go to an internal team. A certified monitoring centre (like one certified to BS 8484) typically offers the fastest response, ensuring help is dispatched quickly in the event of a threat or incident.

Can I access usage data, lone worker reports, and safety trends easily?

Yes, but only if your lone worker solution includes a centralised management portal. Look for systems like SoloProtect Insights, which allow you to track device/app usage, incident history, and worker engagement. This data helps you demonstrate compliance, improve risk assessments, and proactively manage lone worker safety.

Does the solution come with onboarding, training, and ongoing support?

Effective training is essential for adoption and compliance. Choose a provider that offers structured onboarding, user-friendly training materials, and ongoing support. This ensures lone workers understand how to use the safety device or app in real-world situations and that managers can monitor usage effectively.

Does the lone worker solution include GPS tracking for real-time visibility?

Location tracking is crucial for lone worker safety, especially in high-risk environments or for mobile employees. Ensure your solution offers real-time GPS with privacy controls, allowing you to locate workers quickly in emergencies, monitor activity zones, and support lone workers operating across wide geographic areas.

Final Thoughts: It’s Not Just About the Tech

Whether you choose an app, device, or both — your decision should reflect:

Risk profiles
Employee feedback
Legal compliance
Ease of integration
Ongoing support

Both tools can dramatically improve lone worker wellbeing, incident response time, and your organisation’s duty of care — when matched properly to the people using them.